Williamsburg Waterfront Sees Surge in Luxury Buy-Side Deals - Broker Sarah Cotty Leads with Five Closings

By Sarah Cotty, Associate Broker, SERHANT.

Williamsburg Waterfront Sees Surge in Luxury Buy-Side Deals - Broker Sarah Cotty Leads with Five Closings

Discover New York City Beyond the Tourist Guide

Brooklyn & Manhattan Destination Guide | Sarah Cotty

Luxury living area with floor-to-ceiling waterfront windows, curved chairs and a city skyline view.

The Williamsburg waterfront continues to dominate Brooklyn’s luxury real estate market, and no one knows it better than Williamsburg waterfront broker Sarah Cotty, who has already closed five buy-side deals in 2025. 

Market data reinforces the surge: 

  • Williamsburg median sale price reached $1.45M in July 2025, up 4% year-over-year. 

  • Median price per square foot climbed to $1,610, marking a 6.9% increase. 

  • In East Williamsburg, median home values skyrocketed 32.6% year-over-year to $1.72M, representing a staggering 118.7% increase over the past two years. 

  • Homes on the Williamsburg waterfront are moving quickly, with an average days on market of just 38 days, compared to 72 days in East Williamsburg. 

  • Buyers are paying close to ask, with a sale-to-list ratio of 99.4%. 

Meanwhile, inventory pressure remains intense. Only one new listing hit the East Williamsburg market in the last three months, signaling limited opportunities for buyers. 

Sarah Cotty’s success demonstrates the importance of trusted representation in a fast-moving market. “My buyers rely on me for front-row access to new listings and off-market opportunities,” Sarah explains. “With competition this fierce, having strong relationships and local expertise makes all the difference.” 

Waterfront terrace with wooden chaise lounges overlooking the East River and Williamsburg Bridge.

 

 

As Northwest Brooklyn prices surged 21.8% year-over-year, and townhouses rose 25.8%, Williamsburg solidifies its standing as one of New York’s most sought-after neighborhoods. Sarah Cotty continues to lead the way, helping her clients secure premium homes along the waterfront at the best possible value. 

 

✨ Thinking about making a move in Williamsburg? Message Sarah to join her VIP buyer list for front-row access to waterfront opportunities before they hit the market. 

 

📍 Contact: Sarah Cotty at SERHANT

IG: @cottynyc | FB: Sarah Cotty | LinkedIn: Sarah Cotty

X: @cottynyc | YT: @Cottynyc | TikTok: @cottynyc

(917) 207-7590 | [email protected]

Let's connect

Buying or selling in NYC, Miami or Tampa? Let's talk.

Tell me what you want and when. I'll come back with a clear plan and a time to talk.