

A Surprising Bill Count
Mayor Zohran Mamdani announced on X that the city has billed more than $500 million to owners of second homes valued above $5 million.
The Department of Finance sent 17,000 notices over the summer, then narrowed the list to roughly 8,000 properties after processing exemptions.
Who the Tax Targets

The surcharge applies only to secondary one- to three-family homes that exceed the $5 million threshold.
It does not touch primary residences, so the tax is aimed at what many call “luxury pied-à-terres.”
Owners who disagree with a bill can appeal to the city’s Tax Commission for a review.
Legal Pushback

Two lawsuits are currently challenging the surcharge’s constitutionality.
One case comes from the owner of The Montclair co-op on the Upper East Side, joined by several other owners and backed by the Real Estate Board of New York.
City’s Rationale
DOF spokesperson Julia Agos said owning a second home worth over $5 million should carry a responsibility to the city that makes it valuable.
The comment underscores the city’s view that high-value secondary homes should contribute to municipal services.
Whether the tax will meet that goal remains a question for the courts and the Tax Commission.
Questions
How much has NYC billed for the pied-à-terre surcharge?
More than $500 million has been billed to owners of second homes valued above $5 million.
How many properties received a bill after exemptions were processed?
Roughly 8,000 properties received a bill after the Department of Finance processed exemptions.
Who is challenging the tax in court?
The owner of The Montclair co-op and several other owners, supported by the Real Estate Board of New York, have filed lawsuits.
More from Sarah Cotty: buying a home, selling a home, and the market journal.

